Not that it matters to most here, but my new 21 Rigger will be similar to #3, kinda.
Larry Jr.
The sharp edge keeps water from climbing the sponson. That's a good thing. Back in the early 1970s I used to glue a piece of formica to the bottom of the sponson to get the sharp edge both on the rear and both sides. The boat never tripped because the small squared off piece was only a very small portion of the overall non trip angle. The sponsons used to run very clean. Better than rounded painted edges. Now that I think of it, why aint I doing it now?
Like Andy said........all those shapes 1 thru 4 work. The weight of the boat and the speed of the boat in the turns all play into the perfect formula. What works at 8 ponds and 75 mph may not work at 11 pounds and 75 mph. And like "Hydro" said.........it's a combo of the fin and the chine angle that makes for the perfect turning hydro. Just my two cents worth.