I am not cynical. But I have a HUGE personality flaw. I tell people the truth and they get offended. You light into me about my "assumptions"- you haven't even put yours on a boat. Now if you don't mind tell the nice people what your rig sells for in Europe.
Oh gimme a break!! Seriously, the first time I heard this remark was also the first time I had ever been lectured by my parents
Were all grown men here. The only thing that isn't illuminating in this sense is when someone passes off an opinion as the "truth."
im repeating myself for the 3rd time now.
You said "
The first stick you hit will chip the fin." which I clearly disagreed with, as I dont intend to hit any sticks in the first place, certainly not any large enough to damage ANYTHING. In addition, I also stated that regardless, "The point is that it looks amazing, is light, and could/should be a potential option that should be made more viable." YOU are the one whom insisted on forcing your "truth" onto myself and my thread by saying " No sheer bolt and you rip out the sponson transom. If you wanted light the mounting block should be CF. Sorry if I was not suitably amazed." WTF?
As If I dont know what a SHEAR bolt is and their purpose. That, along with your ridiculous condescension were already more than enough to make your point sir. and thats all irrelevant to ANYTHING ANYONE SAID to begin with!
Again, this is now the third time im reiterating the simple purpose for making this thread......As I said first and foremost, I was only sharing pictures of the item as I thought it was interesting, nothing more or less. I wasn't seeking hypothetical theories on how it will perform respective to whatever boat and manner in which I feel like utilizing it in..... Of course as I reiterate, you failed to consider any of this, not that it even matters however, since I am obviously welcoming of all comments..... Ive had this for a long time now and its been simply sitting as I havn't had a boat to use it on yet. I already own a Fantastic turn fin from Mr. Tyndall that the hull has already been drilled and tapped for. It just suddenly occurred to me the other day that perhaps some of the guys here whom appreciate scale detail, would be interested in seeing it..... Apparently it infuriates some unfortunately...
Your carbon fiber turn fin and bracket is definitely a pretty work of art. I can imagine how much effort went into making one of these. However, I think the point that Glenn is trying to make here is that any carbon fiber turn fin is not practical to use when racing R/C boats. If not made properly they can delaminate. When they get chipped, trying to reshape them can ruin the fin ( and THEN they can delaminate ). Aluminum is much more repairable and easier to work with than carbon fiber. I have repaired many turn fins at the races with a file and a hammer and a trailer ball. Anyone who has the talent to make things with carbon fiber ( Terry Keeley comes to mind ) my hat is off to them. Besides, I can't recall seeing any full size hydroplanes using carbon fiber turn fins, much less any aluminum ones that were anodized black. If weight was a factor for using the carbon fiber the number of screws used on your fin would seem to eliminate any weight savings in that department. Nice looking piece, though.
Dick Tyndall
*sigh*
Im fully aware of the point Glenn is making, the point I AM trying to make is that HIS POINT is irrelevant to the thread all together
Ive purchased 2 turn fins from you sir, 1 from Mike Hughes, as well as an Accu-tech turn fin and finally, this unique piece (and thats just 1/8 scale fins). Your two fins came from Virginia, the AC fin came from Florida, and the Hughes fin is literally from about 5 miles away from my home as i type this. The carbon fiber fin however, came overseas from Germany and is itself, very unique, hence why I felt like sharing. Im not trying to act like this is some groundbreaking piece of hardware thats going to outperform everything.... im just tired of this individual by the name of Glenn, carrying on as if this thing is so horridly designed that its apparently not even worth mounting on a boat, or even talking about on a forum......
Im not completely oblivious to the dynamics of turn fins, and even before I ever even remotely thought about picking up an RC boat, this still was not the case