Mark, NJ, others,
We do keep returning to the 1.6 pitch ratio props because they are performing the way we like. The problem with the ABC props is the overly radical cup right at the trailing edge. This is only my opinion based on what I have seen and what I've been told that I agree with. I was told a few years ago by a VERY respected, HIGHLY successful boater that a high pitch progression (increase of pitch from leading edge to trailing edge) is not the best set-up for riggers, because they induce so little load on the prop. This is why the Octura 16xx props work so well on riggers. The have almost no pitch progression.
What I have seen with the ABC props, is alot more load on the engine with little or no increase in speed. They launch better because the pitch progression helps with the increased wetted surface during launch, but when the boat unloads and takes off, the trailing edge cup continues to load the engine throughout the RPM range. If you look at the working face of the blade, where it attaches to the hub, right at the trailing edge, the blade is cupped past parallel with the shaft, causing the blade to have to push through the water like a paddlewheel. This is particularly noticable on the 1.8 pitch ratio props. Eliminate this and you're alot better off.
With the Octura 16xx props, there is very little pitch progression, making them a tougher launch, but once the boat planes out, the engine unloads much better and the throttle response is alot smoother.
With all this said, I think the 1.8 pitch ratio ABC props will be very good with the right modifications. A significant Barr-cut and a fair amount of back-cutting will allow the prop to unload alot more, producing better RPM's, but leaving the reduced rake at the blade tips, which will produce better "shaft torque". We have seen this with the 1718 on our BlackJacks, although we are not ready to start racing with it yet (I have gone back to my 1650 until I can get the 1718 right). I have ran the 2118 on my 45 with limited success. It is just about as fast as the 2116, but is several thousand short on the RPM. If I can get the prop to unload and produce the same RPM as the 2116, the 2118 will be a much faster prop, with less load on the engine.
Don't get me wrong, I'm not knocking the new ABC props. They are very good, especially considering they have only really been on the market for one season. With some refinements, Jim Shaeffer is going to put the screws to Octura. If they don't pay attention, Octura is going to lose alot of business to Jim.
Thanks. Brad.
Titan Racing Components