I think it is a nearly an even trade off with the slight advantage to the Drum engine.
While the crank induction has less drag, the very important flow through the crank is limited compared to the drum. The I.D of the drum is lager than the ID of the crank. We are also able to move the timing window closer to the center of the engine. Something we can't do with the crank because the big bearing is in the way. We have moved this window deeper into the engine since the early versions of the MAC and the torque and power have greatly increased.
With the Drum engine we can use a crank bearing that has less rotating mass, lower ball speed for a givin rpm and yet is stronger. Cheaper too when it needs replacing which is not often.
My main reason for building the crank induction MAC for inboard use is because there are a number of boaters who have existing installations or boat designs that will not easily except the MAC drum engine. For instance, the MAC drum engine will not fit in a Dumas Hawk rigger without major modification and upsetting the center of gravity.
While the crank induction has less drag, the very important flow through the crank is limited compared to the drum. The I.D of the drum is lager than the ID of the crank. We are also able to move the timing window closer to the center of the engine. Something we can't do with the crank because the big bearing is in the way. We have moved this window deeper into the engine since the early versions of the MAC and the torque and power have greatly increased.
With the Drum engine we can use a crank bearing that has less rotating mass, lower ball speed for a givin rpm and yet is stronger. Cheaper too when it needs replacing which is not often.
My main reason for building the crank induction MAC for inboard use is because there are a number of boaters who have existing installations or boat designs that will not easily except the MAC drum engine. For instance, the MAC drum engine will not fit in a Dumas Hawk rigger without major modification and upsetting the center of gravity.