If your time is worth anything, water jugs, milk cartons, and similar containers make poor buoys. One hit and you lose the buoy, the ground tackle, and the location of the buoy. My favorite buoys are 12" styrofoam balls cut in half. I hit one with my hydro Sunday, completely destroyed the buoy, but didn't scratch the boat or loose the ground tackle. I snapped a new buoy on while retreeving my boat and everything was as good as new.
I make these buoys by hot wire cutting the ball in half, making a loop of polypropylene line with a brass snap on it and gluing it into the hole in the buoy with spray foam. This is snapped to a piece of nylon line with a heavy weight (small concrete block) on one end and a light weight (small brick) on the other. This keeps constant tension on the buoy regardless of water level.
Lohring Miller