Futaba receiver antennas getting hot?

Shop deals on ebay
Advertise with us
shop deals on amazon
Intlwaters

Help Support Intlwaters:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
Daniel's Racing said:
One more issue I see with running long antennas.

The extra length going up the tube is just folding over at speed anyhow.

The receiver antenna works considerably better and is meant to be vertically polarized. You ever watch a long antenna tube at 60 mph.

The long antenna tube is bowed over and your long antenna is not an iota taller than the shorter one was and it is laid over flat not sticking up vertical like it should be.

The tube is laid back with the end horizontal and back over or closer to the prop roost.

4-6" straight up or a 8"-12" folded back to the same 4-6" height but now it is laid flat.

The straight 4-6" one is going to give you the better range.

Noticed I haven't almost poked the ole' eye out since we got rid of those long stranded wire antennas the FM radio used to have to have.

The short antenna was all the rave of the 2.4 GHZ. Now you want to go back long for no reason whatsoever.

Decrease your range and maybe poke your eye out too. Nice.

The short vertical antenna will have better range than a long antenna when underway at speed.

9lioNys.jpg
Click to expand...

I've always ran vertical whip on boats and rc cars that can flex.

With stage wireless mic systems we run receiver antennas at 45 degrees relative to vertical as nobody holds a mic vertical. Model aircraft don't use vertical antenna orientation.

Boats are a different animal relative to the RF as they operate on the water. Nobody I've ever seen has held a transmitter with antenna in a vertical orientation. Position varies on transmitter antenna from near vertical to near horizontal - somewhere in between. Worse orientation is transmitter antenna pointed at model, which is easy to do with aircraft.

Speculation for me would be 45 degrees on a boat would be closer to optimal to align with transmitter antenna. Being so close the water vertical as you state may be best for boats. They are a unique application for sure. Just for the record, perpendicular orientation between receiver and transmitter antenna is the worst possible condition.

Something else to think about for sure. :)
 
Wasted wages said:
...........I pulled everything apart, the receiver I chose for the installation had a long antenna on it.

When I popped open the receiver I found the antenna not even attached to the board, and some green corrosion on the IC...

That receiver now resides at the bottom of the lake. That's how I fix radio problems.....
Click to expand...

Same here Frank. I like the way you think.

I recently dumped ethernet routers new still in the box into the recycle bin. First one I installed in a pro audio rack had issues, figured it was a fluke and swapped it out, second one worked. Then sent one to California to a buddy in a rack I built up for him. He too had problems with the router. So, they all went into the recycle bin.

Radio problems, had a few over the years. Back in the early days running Kraft Brick radio's in Veco 19 powered Northwind's radio problems were common. Then I discovered Futaba. I think the Brick's just went into the trash can. But I've definitely sent a few problems to Neptune. :)
 
Terry Keeley said:
Ever notice how some people will go on and on to try and sell their point of view?
Click to expand...

Ever notice how some people are so hardheaded that you have to go on and on to get them to even hear your point of view.

I already knew there was absolutely ZERO chance of you getting it but there are others reading that may have a open mind to some common sense.

You would never understand. It isn't your point of view so it is obviously wrong.
 
Steve White said:
I've always ran vertical whip on boats and rc cars that can flex.

With stage wireless mic systems we run receiver antennas at 45 degrees relative to vertical as nobody holds a mic vertical. Model aircraft don't use vertical antenna orientation.

Boats are a different animal relative to the RF as they operate on the water. Nobody I've ever seen has held a transmitter with antenna in a vertical orientation. Position varies on transmitter antenna from near vertical to near horizontal - somewhere in between. Worse orientation is transmitter antenna pointed at model, which is easy to do with aircraft.

Speculation for me would be 45 degrees on a boat would be closer to optimal to align with transmitter antenna. Being so close the water vertical as you state may be best for boats. They are a unique application for sure. Just for the record, perpendicular orientation between receiver and transmitter antenna is the worst possible condition.

Something else to think about for sure. :)
Click to expand...
I have posted test data on this.. a few years ago.. (its around here someplace)
 
Grimracer said:
I have posted test data on this.. a few years ago.. (its around here someplace)
Click to expand...

If you ever come across it, I'm interested.

Here's a good explanation of things in relative terms: Does antenna orientation (vertical/horizontal) matter?

Most RF noise is known to be vertically polarized. Not suggesting that amounts to a hill of beans with RC models, just a condition worthy of mention for the discussion.

Interesting topic.
 
Just wanted to dig up this old thread for the naysayers that don't believe the issues with short antennas in our boats.

My FAST buddy Mike Nowicki has a brand new JAE 21 and new Futaba 4PM Plus system with R304SB rx that would go maybe 400' and failsafe, the stock antenna was mounted as shown.

We checked everything, battery, switch, radio was dry, antenna tip was taped at the top of the tube, etc. etc. As a last resort we put a long antenna on it and wala, no more issues. YMMV. 🍿


JAE 21.jpg
 
Last edited:
right.. the 304 is not a diversity RX.. so that extremal antenna is ALL YA GOT!..

Team Futaba Marine recommends using a 400mm antenna in all marine applications.

the BEST choice of RX when in an RC boat is a Diversity RX. (the RX will say Diversity right on it!)

Grim
 
Grimracer said:
right.. the 304 is not a diversity RX.. so that extremal antenna is ALL YA GOT!..

Team Futaba Marine recommends using a 400mm antenna in all marine applications.

the BEST choice of RX when in an RC boat is a Diversity RX. (the RX will say Diversity right on it!)

Grim
Click to expand...

From what I've seen I want mine to say FASST on it, do they all practice diversity, equity and inclusion? 🤣
 
Last edited:
Terry Keeley said:
If you've never had a radio box leak, you haven't been boating very long. o_O
Click to expand...
I've been using balloons to put my receivers in been doing it since the early 80s when I started out running Tamiya frogs and hornet since nothing was waterproof back then I even put them on the old school mechanical speed controllers when they had those white ceramic resisters that got hot as hell
 
Terry Keeley said:
Just wanted to dig up this old thread for the naysayers that don't believe the issues with short antennas in our boats.

My FAST buddy Mike Nowicki has a brand new JAE 21 and new Futaba 4PM Plus system with R304SB rx that would go maybe 400' and failsafe, the stock antenna was mounted as shown.

We checked everything, battery, switch, radio was dry, antenna tip was taped at the top of the tube, etc. etc. As a last resort we put a long antenna on it and wala, no more issues. YMMV. 🍿


View attachment 326646
Click to expand...
Define long, in inches, please.
 
Terry
You need to work on that prop. Your throwing too much water up in the air. Not enough thrust out the back........LOL
 
Terry Keeley said:
400mm, close to 16". I use a 12" long antenna tube, like the second drawing:


View attachment 326657
Click to expand...
All of our early Bru-Line antennas were curved due to coil set. At the time I bought virgin nylon in a coil and built a bench and cutter for the girls to cut in 16” lengths. In later years we were able to have our supplier provide it in 64” straight lengths and then we would cut it to 16” straight pieces. Funny, now people want the curved. From an aerodynamic standpoint, if you had a straight one the length as the distance to the tip of the curved one it would probably have the same reception for the receiver as a curved one.
 

Similar threads

J
7PXR Failsafe Mystery-thoughts/advice
2 3
Replies
59
Views
5K
Mike Hughes
Mike Hughes
Timbo Whalen
Found Futaba Receiver Antenna Wire
2
Replies
25
Views
2K
Timbo Whalen
Timbo Whalen
ChrisHerzog
GPS Telemetry question
Replies
15
Views
786
ChrisHerzog
ChrisHerzog
Todd Breda
Need Help To Make My Hydro RTR
Replies
12
Views
934
LohringMiller
LohringMiller
ChrisHerzog
Parts Wanted Looking for a cheap Futaba Tx and Rx
Replies
8
Views
566
Don Ferrette
Don Ferrette

Latest posts

Back
Top