First rule of thumb, one change at a time. Adding some cup is the easiest and generally first thing to do. I recommend taking a desent prop, add some cup until it's hard to get or will not get on the pipe, then start back cutting it until it runs again. Then check to see if your speed and handling has increased.
(I would rather give up some speed to have a better handling boat. To finish first, you have to finish first)
The best way to see what'll happen, take some stock props to the pond with a pair of cupping pliers and start tweakin'.
Once you get to where you'd like to be, then take the numbers off the prop(s) and copy them over to a final one. Let me add to this, just because you've copied the pitch, rake, and cup numbers from one to another does not guarentee it'll be identical in the way it runs. It should be close, just not identical.